Essay 05
Essay 05
Essay 05
Essay 05
My Indian mother was right
My Indian mother was right
My Indian mother was right
My Indian mother was right
25 Oct 2023
25 Oct 2023
25 Oct 2023
25 Oct 2023
4 min
4 min
4 min
4 min
✢ SCROLL TO READ
✢ SCROLL TO READ
✢ SCROLL TO READ
✢ SCROLL TO READ
A distinct smell of cumin seeds, black pepper and ginger wafted through my house. This was a sign that my mother had decided to take my incessant coughing in her own hands and make me ‘kashaya’, a kind of all-healing spice water. If not for this concoction, I was handed ‘haldi doodh’ (turmeric uh, latte?) to cure my ailments. I refused to drink it and demanded benadryl like any rational teenager should. My mother’s home remedies felt like a solution to save money and not necessarily what was ailing me.
A distinct smell of cumin seeds, black pepper and ginger wafted through my house. This was a sign that my mother had decided to take my incessant coughing in her own hands and make me ‘kashaya’, a kind of all-healing spice water. If not for this concoction, I was handed ‘haldi doodh’ (turmeric uh, latte?) to cure my ailments. I refused to drink it and demanded benadryl like any rational teenager should. My mother’s home remedies felt like a solution to save money and not necessarily what was ailing me.
A distinct smell of cumin seeds, black pepper and ginger wafted through my house. This was a sign that my mother had decided to take my incessant coughing in her own hands and make me ‘kashaya’, a kind of all-healing spice water. If not for this concoction, I was handed ‘haldi doodh’ (turmeric uh, latte?) to cure my ailments. I refused to drink it and demanded benadryl like any rational teenager should. My mother’s home remedies felt like a solution to save money and not necessarily what was ailing me.
My mother always had some rationale for her methods. She did all the chores around the house manually, insisting it was exercise. She refused to use a washing machine for a few years because it wasted too much water. She compulsively recycled plastic jars for storing spices and grains because ‘why would you throw away a perfectly good jar?’. Our spice cabinet was nothing like the restock TikTok videos. Nothing was thrown away - all paper, books, metal and clothes were either donated or sold to the “raddiwala”. The raddiwala was a local scrap dealer who paid you Rs. 10 per kilogram of scrap. We excitedly checked how much our trash weighed at the end of every school year because this trash was money that would be divided between us children for ice cream.
My mother prayed everyday, lighting incense and expressing gratitude. Growing up in a farming family, with very little control on outcomes, had made my mother a believer. My brothers and I were growing up in a different India though. We were studying in a missionary school, reciting catholic hymns in the morning assembly and learning science, maths and history in English, a language my mother didn’t speak. We weren't expected to pray everyday except on important religious days. My elder brother, after reading ‘The God Delusion’ by Dawkins, insisted atheism made sense and stopped praying entirely. I was onboard too. My mother let us be. But before an exam, when I was in tears about all the maths I didn’t know, my mother suggested that I pray for courage. In dire times, you don’t question the gods too much, so I closed my eyes and prayed, adding an apology for my astray brother.
My mother and the gods also led to many dietary restrictions. My mother refused to cook meat or fish on Tuesdays and Fridays, these days were special to her gods. My dad refused to eat meat or fish on Mondays and Saturdays, these days were special to his gods (My parents share the same religion so that is a Hindu riddle right there). So we ended up mostly eating rice, lentils and vegetables. We ate fish on Wednesdays and chicken on Sundays, but that was it. During Navratri (a festival) and on the second Tuesday of every month, she fasted. Once I started college, I ate a lot of my meals outside home. Now, I wasn’t arrogant enough to deny the gods but neither was I disciplined enough to abide by their rules.
While the science on smoking was clear, it was ‘a glass of wine daily is good for you’ times. My brothers and I had really caught on to this scientific finding. “Alcohol makes people behave strangely. It cannot be good.” My mother insisted. So we couldn’t drink at home. But we sneakily drank in bars and stayed over with our friends on those nights. She had figured out what was happening but decided to never bring it up.
My mother always had some rationale for her methods. She did all the chores around the house manually, insisting it was exercise. She refused to use a washing machine for a few years because it wasted too much water. She compulsively recycled plastic jars for storing spices and grains because ‘why would you throw away a perfectly good jar?’. Our spice cabinet was nothing like the restock TikTok videos. Nothing was thrown away - all paper, books, metal and clothes were either donated or sold to the “raddiwala”. The raddiwala was a local scrap dealer who paid you Rs. 10 per kilogram of scrap. We excitedly checked how much our trash weighed at the end of every school year because this trash was money that would be divided between us children for ice cream.
My mother prayed everyday, lighting incense and expressing gratitude. Growing up in a farming family, with very little control on outcomes, had made my mother a believer. My brothers and I were growing up in a different India though. We were studying in a missionary school, reciting catholic hymns in the morning assembly and learning science, maths and history in English, a language my mother didn’t speak. We weren't expected to pray everyday except on important religious days. My elder brother, after reading ‘The God Delusion’ by Dawkins, insisted atheism made sense and stopped praying entirely. I was onboard too. My mother let us be. But before an exam, when I was in tears about all the maths I didn’t know, my mother suggested that I pray for courage. In dire times, you don’t question the gods too much, so I closed my eyes and prayed, adding an apology for my astray brother.
My mother and the gods also led to many dietary restrictions. My mother refused to cook meat or fish on Tuesdays and Fridays, these days were special to her gods. My dad refused to eat meat or fish on Mondays and Saturdays, these days were special to his gods (My parents share the same religion so that is a Hindu riddle right there). So we ended up mostly eating rice, lentils and vegetables. We ate fish on Wednesdays and chicken on Sundays, but that was it. During Navratri (a festival) and on the second Tuesday of every month, she fasted. Once I started college, I ate a lot of my meals outside home. Now, I wasn’t arrogant enough to deny the gods but neither was I disciplined enough to abide by their rules.
While the science on smoking was clear, it was ‘a glass of wine daily is good for you’ times. My brothers and I had really caught on to this scientific finding. “Alcohol makes people behave strangely. It cannot be good.” My mother insisted. So we couldn’t drink at home. But we sneakily drank in bars and stayed over with our friends on those nights. She had figured out what was happening but decided to never bring it up.
My mother always had some rationale for her methods. She did all the chores around the house manually, insisting it was exercise. She refused to use a washing machine for a few years because it wasted too much water. She compulsively recycled plastic jars for storing spices and grains because ‘why would you throw away a perfectly good jar?’. Our spice cabinet was nothing like the restock TikTok videos. Nothing was thrown away - all paper, books, metal and clothes were either donated or sold to the “raddiwala”. The raddiwala was a local scrap dealer who paid you Rs. 10 per kilogram of scrap. We excitedly checked how much our trash weighed at the end of every school year because this trash was money that would be divided between us children for ice cream.
My mother prayed everyday, lighting incense and expressing gratitude. Growing up in a farming family, with very little control on outcomes, had made my mother a believer. My brothers and I were growing up in a different India though. We were studying in a missionary school, reciting catholic hymns in the morning assembly and learning science, maths and history in English, a language my mother didn’t speak. We weren't expected to pray everyday except on important religious days. My elder brother, after reading ‘The God Delusion’ by Dawkins, insisted atheism made sense and stopped praying entirely. I was onboard too. My mother let us be. But before an exam, when I was in tears about all the maths I didn’t know, my mother suggested that I pray for courage. In dire times, you don’t question the gods too much, so I closed my eyes and prayed, adding an apology for my astray brother.
My mother and the gods also led to many dietary restrictions. My mother refused to cook meat or fish on Tuesdays and Fridays, these days were special to her gods. My dad refused to eat meat or fish on Mondays and Saturdays, these days were special to his gods (My parents share the same religion so that is a Hindu riddle right there). So we ended up mostly eating rice, lentils and vegetables. We ate fish on Wednesdays and chicken on Sundays, but that was it. During Navratri (a festival) and on the second Tuesday of every month, she fasted. Once I started college, I ate a lot of my meals outside home. Now, I wasn’t arrogant enough to deny the gods but neither was I disciplined enough to abide by their rules.
While the science on smoking was clear, it was ‘a glass of wine daily is good for you’ times. My brothers and I had really caught on to this scientific finding. “Alcohol makes people behave strangely. It cannot be good.” My mother insisted. So we couldn’t drink at home. But we sneakily drank in bars and stayed over with our friends on those nights. She had figured out what was happening but decided to never bring it up.
My mother always had some rationale for her methods. She did all the chores around the house manually, insisting it was exercise. She refused to use a washing machine for a few years because it wasted too much water. She compulsively recycled plastic jars for storing spices and grains because ‘why would you throw away a perfectly good jar?’. Our spice cabinet was nothing like the restock TikTok videos. Nothing was thrown away - all paper, books, metal and clothes were either donated or sold to the “raddiwala”. The raddiwala was a local scrap dealer who paid you Rs. 10 per kilogram of scrap. We excitedly checked how much our trash weighed at the end of every school year because this trash was money that would be divided between us children for ice cream.
My mother prayed everyday, lighting incense and expressing gratitude. Growing up in a farming family, with very little control on outcomes, had made my mother a believer. My brothers and I were growing up in a different India though. We were studying in a missionary school, reciting catholic hymns in the morning assembly and learning science, maths and history in English, a language my mother didn’t speak. We weren't expected to pray everyday except on important religious days. My elder brother, after reading ‘The God Delusion’ by Dawkins, insisted atheism made sense and stopped praying entirely. I was onboard too. My mother let us be. But before an exam, when I was in tears about all the maths I didn’t know, my mother suggested that I pray for courage. In dire times, you don’t question the gods too much, so I closed my eyes and prayed, adding an apology for my astray brother.
My mother and the gods also led to many dietary restrictions. My mother refused to cook meat or fish on Tuesdays and Fridays, these days were special to her gods. My dad refused to eat meat or fish on Mondays and Saturdays, these days were special to his gods (My parents share the same religion so that is a Hindu riddle right there). So we ended up mostly eating rice, lentils and vegetables. We ate fish on Wednesdays and chicken on Sundays, but that was it. During Navratri (a festival) and on the second Tuesday of every month, she fasted. Once I started college, I ate a lot of my meals outside home. Now, I wasn’t arrogant enough to deny the gods but neither was I disciplined enough to abide by their rules.
While the science on smoking was clear, it was ‘a glass of wine daily is good for you’ times. My brothers and I had really caught on to this scientific finding. “Alcohol makes people behave strangely. It cannot be good.” My mother insisted. So we couldn’t drink at home. But we sneakily drank in bars and stayed over with our friends on those nights. She had figured out what was happening but decided to never bring it up.
It is 2023 and studies show my mother was right. We must eat a plant based diet, fast occasionally, meditate, not drink alcohol and be active through the day to live longer. Her recycling habit was just a bonus.
Now, she cooks her chicken curry for us even on Tuesdays and Fridays, when we see her a couple of times every year. Though she still doesn’t eat it. After 15 years of us insisting, she has an occasional glass of wine. But Huberman has declared that alcohol is terrible for our bodies, so I don’t join her.
My mother learnt these ‘rules’ from her mother and a culture that is 5,000 years old. When conflicted about new science now - about what to eat, drink, do - I refer to my culture and my mother. Like other Indian mothers of the 21st century, she is practising a delicate inheritance. Resolving what she must pass on as legacy - recipes, gods, tradition and what she must give even though it wasn’t given to her - independence, equality, choice. My mother allowed me, her science wielding rationally thinking daughter, freedom to rebel against her rules, confident that her values would serve me more. Many years later, I am back to these ‘rules’ wondering what else she was right about.
What’s Huberman saying about not cutting your nails at night?
Get a mail everytime a post goes up.
It will be a reminder to stop scrolling and read something fun.
FEEL FREE TO REACH OUT IF YOU HAVE ANY THOUGHTS OR JUST WANT TO SAY HI.
Design/dev by @itsiddharth
Get a mail everytime a post goes up.
It will be a reminder to stop scrolling and read something fun.
FEEL FREE TO REACH OUT IF YOU HAVE ANY THOUGHTS OR JUST WANT TO SAY HI.
Design/dev by @itsiddharth
Get a mail everytime a post goes up.
It will be a reminder to stop scrolling and read something fun.
FEEL FREE TO REACH OUT IF YOU HAVE ANY THOUGHTS OR JUST WANT TO SAY HI.
Design/dev by @itsiddharth
Get a mail everytime a post goes up.
It will be a reminder to stop scrolling and read something fun.
FEEL FREE TO REACH OUT IF YOU HAVE ANY THOUGHTS OR JUST WANT TO SAY HI.
Design/dev by @itsiddharth